By 1918, the Qing dynasty stands as a modernizing constitutional monarchy, but cracks begin to show in the carefully constructed balance between tradition and reform. Rising nationalism, fueled by resentment of foreign influence and uneven economic progress, collides with conservative elements still loyal to the imperial system. This decade sees fierce political struggles, a growing divide between urban and rural China, and escalating tensions with Japan, culminating in a defining showdown over the future of the Qing dynasty.
Political Developments
The Transition to Majority Rule (1919)
In 1919, the regency council cedes its executive powers to the Guomin Yuan (National Assembly) as the Xuantong Emperor, now 13 years old, formally begins his reign. The Emperor retains symbolic authority, but executive power shifts decisively to a parliamentary system. Liang Qichao becomes China’s first Prime Minister under majority rule, leading a coalition of reformist parties.
This transition is not without resistance. Monarchists and conservative factions, many concentrated in the Guomin Yuan’s appointed upper house, fear that parliamentary rule will erode traditional Confucian values. Liang attempts to bridge the divide by invoking Kang Youwei’s philosophy of “New Confucianism,” arguing that monarchy and modern governance can coexist.
The May Fourth Movement (1919)
China’s role in World War I culminates in bitter disappointment at the Treaty of Versailles. Despite contributions to the Allied war effort, the Qing government fails to secure the return of German-controlled Shandong Province, which is instead awarded to Japan. News of this betrayal sparks massive protests across China, with students, intellectuals, and workers rallying against foreign imperialism and domestic corruption.
The May Fourth Movement pushes Liang Qichao’s government to adopt more radical reforms. Pressured by protests, the government reduces property requirements for voting, expanding the electorate significantly. It also commits to abolishing the unequal treaties imposed by foreign powers, though such efforts are slow to bear fruit.
The Rise of Political Factions
The National Assembly becomes increasingly polarized during the 1920s. Two dominant factions emerge:
- The Constitutional Reformists: Led by Liang Qichao, this faction supports the constitutional monarchy and gradual reform. They advocate cooperation with the West to modernize China’s economy and institutions.
- The Nationalists: Sun Yat-sen’s Nationalist Party (Kuomintang) grows into a formidable opposition force. While still working within the constitutional framework, the Nationalists push for the eventual abolition of the monarchy and the establishment of a republic.
By 1925, the Nationalists control nearly half of the lower house, fueled by popular discontent with the monarchy and the slow pace of reform. Rural elites and urban workers alike begin to view the monarchy as an obstacle to true independence and modernization.
Economic Expansion and Inequality
Continued Industrial Growth
The 1920s see explosive industrial growth in urban centers such as Shanghai, Guangzhou, and Tianjin. Foreign investment, particularly from Britain and the United States, drives the expansion of China’s textile, steel, and chemical industries. The Qing government funds massive infrastructure projects, including the Yangtze River Dam Project, begun in 1923, which aims to control flooding and generate electricity.
China’s railway network also continues to grow, with new lines connecting previously isolated regions like Sichuan and Yunnan to the rest of the empire. By 1928, China boasts the largest railway network in Asia.
Rural Discontent
However, the benefits of industrialization do not reach the countryside. Land reform programs stagnate due to resistance from landlords, and rural poverty remains widespread. Rising taxes to fund infrastructure projects and military expansion exacerbate tensions between peasants and the government. By 1926, rural uprisings become increasingly common, particularly in southern provinces like Hunan and Jiangxi.
Foreign Relations
Tensions with Japan
China’s relationship with Japan deteriorates during this decade. The May Fourth protests spark boycotts of Japanese goods, and anti-Japanese sentiment becomes a rallying cry for both reformists and nationalists. Japan, fearing the growing strength of a unified China, increases its military presence in Manchuria and exerts pressure on the Qing government for new concessions.
In 1927, tensions reach a boiling point when Chinese troops clash with Japanese forces near Mukden (Shenyang). While the skirmish does not escalate into full-scale war, it underscores the fragile peace between the two nations and strengthens calls within China for military readiness.
Western Relations
China’s relationship with the Western powers improves somewhat during the 1920s. The United States supports China’s modernization efforts, providing loans and technical expertise for infrastructure projects. However, Britain and France remain wary of a stronger China, and efforts to renegotiate the unequal treaties meet stiff resistance.
Social and Cultural Developments
The Spread of Education
By 1928, China boasts one of the fastest-growing education systems in the world. Literacy rates among young men reach 60%, and women’s literacy climbs to 30%. Universities in Beijing, Shanghai, and Nanjing become hubs of intellectual activity, producing a generation of thinkers who challenge traditional Confucian norms and advocate for democracy, feminism, and socialism.
The Role of Women
Women’s rights continue to advance, though progress remains uneven. In 1923, women gain the right to vote in local elections, and a handful of female candidates are elected to municipal councils. Foot-binding is virtually extinct by the mid-1920s, and urban women begin to enter professions such as teaching, nursing, and journalism. However, rural women remain largely excluded from these advancements.
Military Modernization
The Beiyang Army’s Dominance
Yuan Shikai’s efforts to modernize the military bear fruit during the 1920s. The Beiyang Army is now a professional, disciplined force equipped with modern weapons produced in Chinese factories. Military academies in Beijing and Nanjing churn out highly trained officers, many of whom have studied abroad in Japan, Germany, or the United States.
Rising Militarism
The military’s growing power, however, raises concerns about its influence on politics. Regional generals, though nominally loyal to the Qing government, begin to act independently, leveraging their military strength to extract concessions from Beijing. By 1928, fears of a military coup loom large, particularly as the Nationalists begin courting disaffected generals to support their republican agenda.
Key Events
The 1924 Shandong Negotiations
After years of diplomatic pressure, Japan agrees to return Shandong Province to Chinese control in 1924. However, the handover comes with significant strings attached, including expanded Japanese economic privileges in Manchuria. While celebrated as a victory, the agreement fuels nationalist anger over continued foreign exploitation.
The Assassination of Liang Qichao (1926)
In 1926, Liang Qichao is assassinated by a radical nationalist while delivering a speech in Nanjing. His death shocks the nation and deepens the divide between monarchists and republicans. Without Liang’s unifying leadership, the Reformist Party fragments, and the Nationalists gain significant ground in the 1927 elections.
The Wuchang Incident (1928)
In 1928, a group of Nationalist-aligned officers stages a mutiny in Wuchang, calling for the abolition of the monarchy. The uprising is quickly crushed by the Beiyang Army, but it marks the first open rebellion against the constitutional system. The incident highlights the growing weakness of the monarchy and sets the stage for a larger confrontation.
By 1928: The State of the Qing Empire
As the decade ends, the Qing dynasty teeters on the edge of collapse. While urban areas thrive under industrialization, rural discontent and nationalist fervor grow unchecked. The young Xuantong Emperor, now 22 years old, struggles to assert his authority in a rapidly changing political landscape.
What If: The Archive 
Leave a comment